Winter Foodie Favorites

Let Middleton's finest baked goods be the star of your holiday meals, creating memories that will last long after the season ends.

Modified December 18, 2025

Whether you're indulging in a hot mulled cider or savoring a seasonal pie, these Middleton winter foodie favorites are sure to make your season even sweeter.

Below, you'll find a dozen delicious options you can enjoy right away—no pre-order required. If looking to bring a taste of Middleton home or share local favorites with your holiday guests, be sure to check out our blog "Sweet Treats to Delight Your Holiday Guests" for a list of holiday pre-order options, perfect for larger items like full pies, cheesecakes, or large orders.

Le C's Patisserie & Tea House

608-440-4106
LECSTEA.COM

Does it feel like something's been missing from your holiday season? It's likely Le C's Patisserie & Tea House's pinecone-shaped mousse cake, a festive and delicious treat made with chocolate mousse, hazelnut cake, and rich chocolate ganache. Don't miss their Santa hat-shaped dessert with raspberry and pistachio mousse filling for a truly unique bite.

Five holiday-themed desserts on a marble table: a red gift box, a Christmas tree, a chestnut Mont Blanc, a pinecone, and a Santa hat.

Grace Coffee Co.

715-350-2425
GRACECOFFEEWI.COM

Grace Coffee Co. is serving up a delicious selection of seasonal treats to keep you cozy all season long. Warm up with the gingerbread latte, made with signature house-made gingerbread syrup and spices, available hot or iced. Spice fans will love the Mexican mocha, a bold twist on the classic mocha with cinnamon, cayenne, and chili pepper for a bit of heat. And for a refreshing winter treat, don’t miss the peppermint mocha or gingerbread chai. Not much of a coffee drinker? Hop on the dirty soda trend with the candy cane Italian cream soda, featuring a blend of peppermint and vanilla, sparkling water, cream and crushed candy cane.

Pair these drinks with a sweet bite, like pecan pie overnight oats or an irresistible white chocolate cranberry parfait (so good they're flying off the shelves).

A latte with latte art, topped with cinnamon sticks, a chocolate square, and surrounded by red chilies, sits on a wooden table near a decorated Christmas tree.
Mexican Mocha
A black cup of coffee with latte art, a piece of peppermint bark, and a chocolate bar on a saucer. Surrounded by peppermint candies and festive greenery.
Peppermint Mocha

Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream

608-203-5228
CHOCOLATESHOPPEICECREAM.COM

Who says ice cream is only for the summer? Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream serves up delightful seasonal flavors that are perfect for the colder months. Enjoy favorites like Cinnamon Stick, Caramel Apple Pie, and Egg Nog, or indulge in the festive Gingerbread Man — a brown sugar gingerbread ice cream swirled with white icing glaze and topped with holiday sprinkles. While Peppermint Stick is available year-round, it tastes even better during the holiday season. These seasonal treats are the perfect way to enjoy ice cream, no matter the weather!

Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream has joined the advent calendar scene with its very own 12 Days of Ice Cream Advent Calendar. It's the perfect excuse to start each day with a mini cup of ice cream with classic flavors and festive surprises, each with a scratch-off flavor reveal.

Ice cream cone with two scoops of vanilla and cookie chunks, decorated with cartoon gingerbread characters wearing Santa hats.
Gingerbread Man Ice Cream

Miggy's Bakes

608-445-4332
MIGGYSBAKES.COM

Miggy's Bakes offers not only the most Insta-worthy creations but also some of the tastiest treats. Enjoy their edible cookie dough served in Christmas cookie cups, with festive flavors such as chocolate peppermint, hot chocolate, chocolate chip, and sugar cookie snowflakes. They also offer a variety of homemade cookies, including ginger molasses, and delectable dessert treats like peppermint bark, Ritz toffee, and even homemade Little Debbie Cakes. Each creation is designed to satisfy your holiday cravings in the most delicious way.

Decorated sugar cookies shaped like Santa Claus faces, featuring red hats, white icing beards, and pink cheeks.
Christmas Sugar Cookies
An assortment of cookie dough treats topped with chocolate drizzle, crushed cookies, and a small chocolate bar piece on one.
Cookie Cups
A tray of assorted holiday cookies with festive decorations is set on a table in front of a Christmas tree with ornaments and lights.
Christmas Cookie Mix

Hubbard Avenue Diner

608-831-6800
HUBBARDAVENUEDINER.COM

Hubbard Avenue Diner, is bringing festive flavors to your holiday table with a selection of seasonal desserts. This December, try the candy cane pie, a delicious combination of a chocolate ganache crust, peppermint filling, and a topping of crushed candy canes and chocolate shavings. For a comforting, spiced option, gingerbread pie is made with a deep molasses and ginger blend and Hubbard's new eggnog pie is perfect for the season. There is also a vegan pear apple pie, ensuring there's something for everyone. These seasonal pies are only available until the end of the month, so make sure to enjoy them while you can!

For those looking to switch things up, the diner has a selection of festive treats, including snowman cupcakes, holiday sugar cookies and several cake options, and a yule log with layers of chocolate mousse and ganache for a fun and festive touch.

A cream pie with chocolate shavings and crushed peppermint on top sits on a metallic cake stand.
Candy Cane Pie
Chocolate cupcake topped with icing shaped like a snowman, decorated with red earmuffs and scarf, on an orange background.
Snowman Cupcake
A pie topped with white cream swirls and gingerbread cookies on a white cake stand.
Gingerbread Pie
Plate with a snowman cookie and two snowflake cookies on a snowy backdrop, surrounded by pine branches.
Holiday Sugar Cookies

Clasen's European Bakery

608-831-2032
CLASENSBAKERY.COM

Clasen's European Bakery boasts a tempting selection of festive treats to enhance your holiday celebrations. From rich chocolate to a flavorful rum fruit cake, there’s something to satisfy every craving. No matter your preference, you're sure to find the perfect sweet to enjoy this season.

With 15 varieties of holiday cookies, including classic European favorites like marzipan printen and heidensand, there’s a cookie for all tastes. Don’t miss the peppermint crunch, a rich chocolate butter cookie coated in dark chocolate and topped with crushed peppermint candies. For a true festive indulgence, try the yule log or the holiday stollen, a light, sweet coffee cake dough filled with walnuts, candied fruit, and golden raisins, all topped with more fruit and walnuts.

Bags of marzipan printen on display at a market stall, wrapped in blue and red packaging with labels. Pricing details are visible on the signs below.
15 Varieties of Holiday Cookies
Stack of chocolate-covered cookies with peppermint pieces next to a bag of more cookies. A partially eaten cookie shows the interior.
Peppermint Crunch
Chocolate yule log cake with festive decorations on a wooden surface, surrounded by pine branches and red berries.
Yule Log
A festive dessert with icing and colorful candied fruits, placed on a wooden surface. Pine branches and pinecones surround the dish.
Holiday Stollen
Gingerbread house display with "Clasen Bakery" written on it, surrounded by containers of cookies in a bakery setting.
Cookie Medley Holiday Sampler

Winter Foodie - Seasonal Spirits Edition

Tinseltown

608-571-5910
TINSELTOWNBARMIDDLETON.COM

Celebrate the holiday season at Middleton’s festive pop-up bar, Tinseltown. Immerse yourself in the over-the-top holiday decorations while enjoying tasty bar snacks and seasonal cocktails. You can upgrade your standard-sized $8 holiday drink to the jumbo “Experience” for just $13 — perfect for sharing with friends. Sip on fun, pun-filled drinks like Cindy Lou Who Espresso Martini, Clasumo, Jingle Juice, and more! But hurry — Tinseltown is only open for the season and will close on Dec. 31, 2025, so don’t miss out!

A person with curly hair sips from a large copper mug using a red straw. The background is decorated with colorful lights.
Yule Mule Experience
A person holds a cocktail menu featuring holiday-themed drinks. The background is colorful and out of focus.
Festive Drink Menu
A martini glass with a brown cocktail next to a large copper mug filled with ice, mint, and a candy cane on a snowflake-patterned tablecloth.
Yule Mule & Cindy Lou Who Espresso Martini

Capital Brewery & Bier Garten

608-836-7100
CAPITALBREWERY.COM

Capital Brewery is celebrating the season with its Winter Skal, a full-bodied Vienna-style lager that features a warm amber hue and showcases its rich malt heritage. With a mild bitterness and a hop presence that perfectly complements the malt overtones, it's a brew that balances warmth and flavor.

For a late Winter Foodie brew, mark your calendars for Saturday, Feb. 28, as Capital Brewery hosts the 29th Annual Bockfest to celebrate the release of its platinum award-winning Blonde Doppelbock and Maibock. This lively event promises not only delicious seasonal beers but also live music, a fish toss, and the fun "1K Running of the Blondes." Be sure to check out the Bockfest traditions here and grab your tickets for this one-of-a-kind celebration here!

Capital Brewery's Winter Skål beer selection on snow, featuring a can, bottle, and pint glass against a wintry backdrop.
Winter Skal
Person holding a mug labeled "Capital Brewery Bockfest 2024," partially filled with beer. A pretzel necklace is visible in the background.
Blonde Doppelbock

Hidden Cave Cidery

608-213-7396
HIDDENCAVECIDERY.COM

Hidden Cave Cidery is a local gem serving Wisconsin-made hard ciders on tap and for sale. Warm up on Fridays and Saturdays this winter with a hot mulled cider. They also feature a Honeysuckle French Toast cider, a semi-sweet blend of cinnamon, nutmeg, vanilla, salt, pure Wisconsin maple syrup, and honeysuckle for a warm, flavorful experience.

A glass of light-colored liquid with a cinnamon stick inside, placed on a white surface with blurred background lighting.
Mulled Cider

Cooper's Hawk Winery & Restaurant

608-716-7775
CHWINERY.COM

Celebrate the season at Cooper’s Hawk Winery and Restaurant with two limited-time cocktails that bring a festive twist to the menu. The Winter White Cooler blends Grand Marnier, winter white wine and spiced cranberries, while the Cranberry Aperol Spritz features a red sangria base mixed with spiced cranberry syrup, Aperol and prosecco. Both drinks are available through January 5 and are just $8 during happy hour (Monday through Friday from 3 to 5:30 p.m.). For wine lovers, the front tasting area also offers wine flights, making it easy to find the perfect pairing for any holiday meal.

Two women walk past a wooden wine display filled with bottles in a well-lit store, browsing for the perfect pairing to complement their winter food selections.
Posted in ,