Soups for Every Season

Dive into Middleton’s soup scene, where every bowl is packed with comfort and local flavor.

Winter in Wisconsin can be a beautiful snowy wonderland, but also quite cold, and there's nothing better than a hot bowl of soup to help beat the chill. From savory broths to creamy concoctions, we've rounded up five must-try soups from local restaurants that will make this winter feel a little warmer.

Longtable Beer Cafe

First up is the Beer Cheddar Soup at Longtable Beer Cafe, a cozy spot where craft beer, great food, and lively conversation come together. This inviting cafe, bottle shop and tasting room offers the perfect atmosphere for enjoying good company and even better eats. The Beer Cheddar Soup, priced at $6 for a cup and $9 for a bowl, is a must-try. Made with Amber ale, Hook’s 1-year cheddar, and Sassy Cow milk and cream, it's a rich and hearty vegetarian dish. For the ultimate pairing, choose from the restaurant's 300 bottled beers or 12 rotating taps to complement any meal. Ask about the soup of the day!

A sandwich with white bread, leafy greens, tomato, and filling next to a bowl of creamy soup topped with cracker pieces. The items are on a printed paper-lined tray.

Sofra Family Bistro

Sofra Family Bistro’s Albanian Wedding Soup has been delighting locals for more than 19 years. Known for authentic Albanian-American dishes, Sofra offers a warm, family-friendly atmosphere perfect for enjoying comforting meals. The Albanian Wedding Soup is a standout, with a flavorful combination of whole milk yogurt, fresh mint, angel hair pasta, garlic, and a splash of lemon juice, all enriched with heavy cream. It’s just one of Sofra's rotating soups — others like French onion and chicken wild rice (both are also house-made) are also worth trying, but the wedding soup is a unique crowd favorite.

Two bowls of soup, a fresh salad with dressing, and sliced bread on a tray.

Hubbard Avenue Diner

At Hubbard Avenue Diner, diners find comfort food done right, including its classic White Chicken Chili. Always available on the menu, this hearty dish comes served with green onions, Monterey Jack cheese, and a side of cornbread. If in the mood for something extra, order it Frito-style—this means a pile of crunchy Fritos topped with chili and all the favorite toppings, like cheese and onions. Whether going for a cup ($6.99) or a bowl ($8.99), this cozy diner provides warmth any day of the week. And, of course, no visit is complete without a slice of one of their famous pies to round out the meal.

Bowl of chili topped with shredded cheese and green onions, with a spoon inside. Plate of cornbread in the background.

Trio Ramen

If craving an authentic and customizable ramen experience, Trio Ramen in Middleton is the place to be. With ingredients sourced directly from Japan, they craft each bowl with house-made broth and noodles, offering a truly genuine taste. Whether preferences lie with Tonkotsu, Miso, Shoyu, or a vegetarian broth, Trio Ramen builds the perfect bowl by allowing diners to choose a broth, protein and toppings. There are also plenty of ramen options to try that do not require customization. The best part? Trio Ramen is owned and operated by three passionate women from Middleton who are always eager to assist with selections and answer any questions. It’s a local gem where warmth and flavor come together in every bowl!

A bowl of ramen with broth, sliced pork, half a soft-boiled egg, narutomaki, green onions, bamboo shoots, pickled ginger, and a sheet of nori on a wooden table.

Craftsman Table & Tap

Craftsman Table & Tap offers a comforting take on a classic with a Creamy Tomato Basil Soup, served with crispy garlic croutons for the perfect crunch. If craving something a little more indulgent, the Grilled Cheese is a must-try—this isn't an average sandwich. Filled with a rich blend of Colby, Gruyere, and Havarti cheeses, sour cream and onion potato chips for extra flavor, it is grilled between buttery challah bread. To top it off, this meal comes with a shooter of tomato basil soup, making this dish the ultimate pairing. The tomato soup is available for $6, with the grilled cheese combo for $12; both are sure to warm a body with every bite.

A bowl of tomato soup topped with croutons and herbs, placed on a white saucer with a spoon beside it on a wooden table. A blurred plate of green beans is in the background.

The soup craze doesn't stop here. Check out a list below of more soup options in Middleton.

Posted in

Modified February 11, 2025