Where to Shop Resale, Thrift & Consignment in Middleton
Find one-of-a-kind treasures, vintage favorites and pre-loved goods at shops throughout Middleton.
There’s something special about finding a great secondhand piece, especially when it’s one-of-a-kind. Middleton has plenty of places to hunt for those unexpected treasures, with shops specializing in resale, consignment, thrift, vintage and estate items.
From stylish furniture and home decor to clothing, jewelry and collectibles, these shops are full of pieces with plenty of character and stories to tell.
University Coin & Jewelry
A Middleton fixture for more than 25 years, University Coin & Jewelry offers an extensive selection of new and vintage jewelry and watches, with an assortment of coins, collectibles and other unique finds mixed in. Browse diamonds, gold and silver jewelry, luxury and vintage watches, U.S. and foreign coins, military collectibles and more. The knowledgeable staff can also help uncover the value in items brought in, making this a fun stop for jewelry lovers, watch enthusiasts and collectors alike.
RTC Estate Sales & Consignment
This one is a hidden gem, tucked next to the historic 1847 at the Stamm House and sharing its parking lot is RTC Estate Sales & Consignment. Inside the 4,500-square-foot store, shoppers can browse a thoughtfully curated mix of antiques, vintage and other hard-to-find pieces. Owners Steve and Melissa started RTC in 2009 and have built the business around helping families locate new homes for meaningful belongings, including estate liquidations and individual consignors. It’s a fun stop for anyone who enjoys the thrill of uncovering something with a rich history. Currently, the store is only open Fridays and Saturdays from 10 a.m. – 4 p.m., with plans to permanently expand hours this fall.
Simply Savvy
A consignment shop with plenty to explore, Simply Savvy is the kind of place where a quick browse can turn into a great find. Most of the shop is filled with high-quality resale furniture, home decor, housewares, rugs, lighting, clothing, accessories and jewelry, with pieces for both men and women. Mixed among the consignment are items from local artists, adding another layer of unique discoveries to the shopping experience. Simply Savvy also shares new arrivals regularly on social media.
Yada Fair Trade & Resale
Yada Fair Trade & Resale is more than a place with gently used clothing, furniture and household goods. The shop also carries fair-trade artisan goods, with store proceeds supporting Yada’s mission to empower women affected by trafficking. Beyond the store, The Yada Project offers free car care clinics, an addiction recovery group and a welcoming space for connection. Learn more about their story here.
The Cozy Home - Middleton
With three locations throughout Dane County, including Middleton, The Cozy Home specializes in consigned new and vintage furniture and home décor in a variety of styles. Owned and operated by a mother-daughter duo, the shop regularly shares new arrivals on social media, making it a great idea to check in often. And since it’s located directly next to University Coin & Jewelry, it’s easy to make a stop at both while on the journey of exploring Middleton’s resale shops.
Goodwill - Middleton
Pretty much everyone has been to a Goodwill, but not all Goodwill stores are created equal. The Middleton location has earned a reputation for being a standout spot for secondhand shopping, with a mix of clothing, furniture, household goods and unexpected finds worth digging through the racks for. One Google reviewer summed it up perfectly, “a lot of other locations are lackluster but Middleton always has like at least one thing that I want. I'd consider it the flagship of the Goodwill Dane County brand.”